Why stone classifications are often confusing
Unlike diamonds, which have an internationally recognized grading system with the famous “4Cs” (Carat, Color, Clarity, Cut), semi-precious stones and minerals have no official global standard for assessing their quality. The grades assigned to natural stones—A, AA, AAA, AAAA, AB, or “Gem Grade”—vary significantly depending on:
- countries;
- wholesalers;
- lapidaries;
- cutting workshops;
- and retailers.
In other words, an AAA grade from one supplier may sometimes correspond to a simple AA from another.
This lack of a universal standard explains why stone classifications can seem vague or even contradictory.
How is a stone’s quality determined?
Before even discussing grades, it’s important to understand the criteria actually used to evaluate a natural stone.
Color intensity and beauty
Color is often the primary criterion.
A stone with an intense, deep, and harmonious hue will generally be more sought-after than a pale or dull stone.
Certain stones have particularly prized shades:
- the royal blue of lapis lazuli;
- the deep purple of amethyst;
- or the intense green of certain malachites.
Transparency
For transparent or translucent stones, clarity plays an important role.
A clear and luminous stone will often be valued more highly than a cloudy or opaque one.
However, some opaque stones can be highly sought-after despite a complete lack of transparency, especially when their color or patterns are exceptional.
Natural inclusions
Inclusions are the visible elements inside the stone:
- internal fissures;
- veils;
- cavities;
- crystallizations;
- or mineral inclusions.
Some inclusions decrease the stone’s value, while others can actually enhance its natural character and authenticity.
In the case of lapis lazuli, for example, golden pyrite inclusions are often appreciated.
The stone’s luster
A high-quality stone generally displays a pleasant and lively luster.
Some stones appear more luminous, silkier, or more lustrous depending on their composition and the quality of polishing.
Polishing and cutting quality
Even a beautiful rough stone can lose tremendous value if it’s poorly worked.
Uneven polishing, scratches, asymmetrical cutting, or mediocre finishes can significantly diminish a stone’s perceived quality.
Fissures and fragility
Visible fissures or fragile areas can reduce a stone’s durability and value.
Some natural stones naturally have microfissures, but their significance varies among specimens.
Possible treatments
Many stones sold on the market have undergone treatments:
- heating;
- irradiation;
- dyeing;
- resin impregnation;
- stabilization;
- or reconstitution.
These treatments don’t automatically make a stone “fake,” but they can influence its value and should ideally be disclosed transparently. Some stones are almost systematically treated in commerce without this necessarily diminishing their appeal or beauty.
This is particularly the case with many blue topazes, whose color is generally obtained through irradiation treatment followed by heating.
Most tanzanites on the market are also heated to reveal or intensify their famous blue-violet color. Naturally very blue tanzanites without treatment do exist, but they remain much rarer.
What do the different grades mean?
The most commonly used classification in Europe generally relies on grades ranging from C to AAA, or even AAAA or “Gem Grade.”
Be careful, however: this is not an official system but an approximate commercial convention.
Indicative table of the most common grades
| Grade | General meaning |
| C | Low quality, numerous inclusions/many visible defects, weak color intensity |
| B | Rather low to medium quality, visible inclusions and defects |
| AB | Intermediate quality between B and A |
| A | Good overall quality with some visible defects |
| AA | Good quality with more uniform color and fewer inclusions |
| AAA | Very good quality, rich color and beautiful finish |
| AAAA | Selected superior quality |
| Gem Grade / Extra / Museum Grade | Very high quality or exceptional quality |
Grades elsewhere in the world
Classification systems can vary significantly depending on producing countries, wholesalers, and local commercial traditions.
| Region / Country | Commonly used system | Characteristics |
| Europe | C to AAAA / Gem Grade | Most widespread commercial classification in jewelry and crystal healing |
| China / India / Thailand | 1A to 7A | The higher the number of “A”s, the higher the stone’s supposed quality |
| Brazil | D / C / B / A / EE / SE | “SE” often means “Super Extra” |
| Madagascar | C / B / A / A++ | A++ generally corresponds to the most carefully selected stones |
| Uruguay | 1 to 6 | System mainly used for certain Uruguayan amethysts; 6 generally corresponds to the finest qualities |
In Asia, particularly in China or India, certain classifications can be used in a very marketing-oriented way. It’s not uncommon to see designations like AAAA, Premium Grade, or Super Extra,
In Brazil and Madagascar, grades often place greater emphasis on:
- color intensity;
- polishing quality;
- visual purity;
- and specimen rarity.
In Uruguay, numerical classifications are particularly well-known for amethysts. The highest grades generally correspond to crystals displaying a deep, uniform, and well-saturated purple color.
Abusive commercial practices
The absence of an international standard unfortunately leaves room for certain commercial abuses.
Some unscrupulous sellers don’t hesitate to:
- artificially inflate grades;
- use prestigious designations without real justification;
- or assign AAA to medium-quality stones to justify higher prices.
It’s therefore important to remain cautious when faced with overly flattering classifications.
A reputable seller will generally favor:
- honest descriptions;
- realistic photographs;
- transparency about possible treatments;
- and clear explanations about the actual quality of the stones offered.
Classifications can serve as useful reference points, but they should never be considered absolute standards.

